?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Answer for question 4308.

If you enjoy the Harry Potter book series, which book/year is your favorite and why? What are your favorite parts in that particular book? How do you think the movies compared to the books?
By far, my favorite of the HP books is Prisoner of Azkaban. I feel the story is the tightest of all of them, and with the introduction of James' three friends and their relationship with Snape into the contemporary story, we start to see the history that's shaping Harry now; after all, the events of the series are completely shaped by the events at Hogwarts 50 years ago and 20 years ago. I also feel that it's the last of the good adventure novels. JK excels at lighter single adventures with blindsiding plot twists, and her later books got either too outrageous with its insane machinations (Goblet of Fire), or too serious and talky, which she doesn't do as well.

I haven't read Prisoner of Azkaban in quite a while, so I can't really remember a favorite part of the book.

As far as the movies are concerned, in general, they're nowhere near as good as the books. Philosopher's Stone captured the wonder of the world of magic so well - and it's what drew me into the series - but that was lost in the subsequent films. Prisoner of Azkaban was pretty faithful to the book, and it flowed very well, with its seasonal scene transitions to show the passage of time. But the others, while entertaining, were nothing special. A lot of it has to do with trying to stuff the books into two hours - they really needed to extend the movies or break them into two parts. I just watched Chamber of Secrets last week, and the jerky scene switching left me actually a bit nauseous. And I'll never forgive what they did to Goblet of Fire, gutting Barty Jr.'s backstory (which was one of the only good parts of the book) and making him a one-dimensional psychopath in favor of extending Harry's genius dive-and-snatch into a multiple minute CGI dragon chase (and other fluff).

Comments

( 4 comments — Leave a comment )
a_phoenixdragon
Apr. 3rd, 2015 09:07 pm (UTC)
Yeah, they did water down Barty Jr's fall from grace. Which was a major turning point in the series. But the last couple of books were definitely my favs...


*HUGS*
shivver13
Apr. 5th, 2015 02:26 am (UTC)
Actually, what I'm referring to is being led believe that he'd been innocent and unfairly condemned by Barty Sr. because he'd been a disappointment and his father didn't want to show weakness and favoritism (if I remember correctly; it's been years since I read it). And then it turns out he really had been evil, in response to his poor relationship with his father. In the film, he was obviously a Death Eater from the moment he swaggered into the courtroom. With the former backstory, his machinations were fascinating (even though, really, Barty, you should have just invited Harry out for a butterbeer in Hogsmeade and made the glass a Portkey); in the movie, he was just another psycho.
a_phoenixdragon
Apr. 6th, 2015 12:37 am (UTC)
I see...and I totally get you. I have no love for the Minister and I think he created all of his own problems, really. How he handled his son...well, honestly - what did he expect in the end?!
flowsoffire
Apr. 12th, 2015 07:40 pm (UTC)
gutting Barty Jr.'s backstory (which was one of the only good parts of the book) and making him a one-dimensional psychopath in favor of extending Harry's genius dive-and-snatch into a multiple minute CGI dragon chase (and other fluff).
God, don't even tell me. I loved Barty! ♥
( 4 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

February 2018
S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728   
Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by chasethestars